We publish the scoring system. We score against it.
valUX is a UK specialist visibility agency that publishes the scoring rubric before scoring any site against it. The rubric is seven weighted categories, the rules are public, and every audit is signed by a named architect. Most SEO audits cannot be checked. This one can.
The usual SEO audit problem is unverifiability: recommendations without a baseline, scores tied to a single tool, visibility defined differently each quarter, and findings buyers cannot reproduce. The valUX method fixes that with a published rubric, fixed scoring rules, and re-runnable checks, in line with the mixed-method evaluation pattern Nielsen Norman Group recommends for trustworthy research.
The usual audit problem
Recommendations without a measurable baseline
Scores that depend on the tool
Visibility defined differently each quarter
Findings that are hard to reproduce
The valUX method
Published scoring rubric
Same score formula every month
Fixed audit shape
Re-runnable checks
Clear evidence behind each score
Why a published rubric matters: the search platforms themselves keep telling us so.
“Our systems aim to reward original, high-quality content that demonstrates the qualities of what we call E-E-A-T.”
Google Search Central·Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content·developers.google.com
03Four commitments behind every audit
What makes a valUX audit trustworthy?
A valUX audit earns trust through four standing commitments: a published rubric every buyer can read, a named technical lead who signs the report, an identical audit shape on every engagement, and tagged evidence behind every score that the client can re-run.
Published rubric
The 7 categories, weights, and rules are public.
Named technical lead
Every audit is led and signed by a real person.
Same audit shape
Same sections, same artefacts, every time.
Reproducible evidence
Checks can be re-run and evidence re-verified.
04How every audit is built
Same shape. Same artefacts. Every site.
Every Pulse audit follows the same four-step build: a composite score, the seven weighted categories that produced it, the tagged findings under each category, and a 12-week implementation plan. Three reproducible probe groups (technical, crawlability, citation) feed those steps on every site. The technical probes include the loading, interactivity and visual-stability metrics defined by web.dev's Core Web Vitals programme.
Score
Composite score
Categories
7 weighted categories
Findings
Tagged findings
12-week Plan
Implementation plan
Technical visibility
·Core Web Vitals
·Indexation and coverage
·Structured data
·Internal linking
Crawlability
·Robots.txt and sitemaps
·HTTP status and redirects
·Crawl depth and budget
·Canonical health
Citation eligibility
·Brand entity signals
·E-E-A-T and trust signals
·Mentions and references
·Source proximity
Three reproducible probe groups feed the score. Evidence is tagged and stored with every report.
05Named accountability
If it ships, someone signs it.
Named accountability means every report is tied to a real person with a published role, not a faceless queue. The technical architect signs the audit, the editorial lead signs the writing, and both names appear on the readout.
Dyno
Founder & Web Architect
Responsible for technical audit shape, scoring systems, and final readout.
Signs every audit.
Maya Sen
Insights Writer
Responsible for research interpretation and evidence-backed editorial clarity.
Signs every audit.
Every report is tied to a named person, not a faceless queue.
06See the system
See the system before you buy.
Three artefacts let buyers inspect the method before committing: the seven-category rubric on the scoring page, the deliverables list that ships with every audit, and the audit catalogue that compares Pulse Essentials, Growth, and X side by side.
A valUX audit is a measured baseline plus an implementation plan, not a one-page checklist, a quick-win audit, or a retainer funnel. It suits teams that need a verifiable starting score, buyers who want evidence before implementation, and organisations comparing Google and AI visibility on one rubric, grounded in the empirically-tested GEO optimisation patterns published in the Princeton-led KDD 2024 GEO paper.
This is not
a one-page checklist
a quick-win audit
a retainer funnel
This is for
teams that need a measurable baseline
buyers who want evidence before implementation
teams comparing Google and AI visibility
A fixed system. A visible method. A result you can question. Before you buy. After you buy. Any time.
08Start with confidence
Start with a method you can inspect.
Get a score, the evidence behind it, and a plan your team can challenge, use, and repeat.